However, as scary as Blackbeard and his crew are, one thing has cast a veil of mystery around their actions: One Piece‘s tendency to skip over their fights. Numerous clashes involving the pirates have been off-screened, and at this point in the franchise, it’s become a running joke that the Blackbeard Pirates will almost always win their battles — just not where fans can see them.
Blackbeard Gave Shanks His Scar 15 Years Before One Piece’s Story



Roughly 15 years before One Piece‘s core story, Blackbeard gave Shanks the three-pronged scar seen over his left eye. While the two are clearly enemies, the reason for Blackbeard giving Shanks this scar, as well as how it happened, remains unknown. Thankfully, this mystery will almost certainly be explained when the pair of Emperors make their moves in One Piece‘s final saga, so fans can rest easy knowing this is one off-screen Blackbeard fight that won’t always be a mystery.
Wapol Left Drum Island to Escape Blackbeard
Only a few months before the events of One Piece‘s core story, the Blackbeard Pirates attacked Drum Kingdom and forced Wapol and his subordinates to flee the island. The specifics of this battle are almost completely unknown, yet somehow, Wapol escaped with his life. Since the overeating antagonist is still relevant to the story, there’s always the chance that Wapol sheds light on his clash with Blackbeard at some point in the future.
Ace’s Defeat Was the First Sign That Blackbeard Was the Off-Screen King




If Blackbeard’s mention in the Drum Island Arc introduces the idea of him winning fights off-screen, then his defeat of Portgas D. Ace solidifies it as a recurring trend. Blackbeard’s future would prove to hold many more off-screen battles, yet none had the far-reaching complications that his defeat of Ace did.
Magellan Failed to Defeat Blackbeard Before the Marineford Arc
Of all the characters introduced in One Piece‘s Impel Down Arc, none are more intimidating than the prison’s warden, Magellan. His Venom-Venom Fruit is incredibly deadly, and it nearly kills Luffy when the two square off in the bowels of the prison. That said, the hyperlethal warden is somehow defeated by Blackbeard during the Warlord of the Sea’s jailbreak of Impel Down, which happens off-screen during the beginning of the Marineford Arc.
Whitebeard Lost His Devil Fruit to Blackbeard Behind a Literal Curtain




Technically, Blackbeard’s defeat of Whitebeard is shown on-screen; however, the most important part of this scene — Blackbeard’s theft of Whitebeard’s Devil Fruit — is obscured by a curtain, preventing fans and the combatants at Marineford from seeing the unprecedented event.
Marco and the Whitebeard Pirates Fell to Blackbeard During the Timeskip
Blackbeard’s murder of Whitebeard is tragic, but it isn’t the notorious pirate’s only crime against his former crew. In an attempt to avenge Whitebeard, the deceased pirate’s first mate, Marco, leads the remnants of the Whitebeard Pirates in an attack on Blackbeard’s crew during the timeskip, which results in the Whitebeard Pirates’ resounding defeat.
A lot happens during One Piece‘s two-year timeskip, so it’s not surprising that the fight between the Blackbeard and Whitebeard Pirates was never depicted in Eiichiro Oda’s manga nor the anime adaptation. However, it’s still one of the most disappointing off-screen fights that was off-screened, if for no other reason than it prevented Marco from finally getting to showcase his skills in a starring role.
Ochoku Lost Pirate Island to Blackbeard During the Rocky Port Incident
Every Emperor of the Sea has a concentrated area of influence in the New World, and in Blackbeard’s case, he and his crew operate out of Pirate Island. This location (also known as Hachinosu) has a rich history of piracy, and until the events of the timeskip, it was ruled by one of the surviving members of Rocks D. Xebec’s crew, Ochoku.
Blackbeard Clashed With the Revolutionary Army & Cipher Pol at Baltigo
For the most part, One Piece‘s pirates rarely interact with the Revolutionary Army, as their conflict predominantly revolves around the World Government and its wrongdoings. However, after Jesus Burgess is bested by Sabo in the Dressrosa Arc, he helps Blackbeard launch an off-screen attack on the Revolutionary Army’s base in Baltigo that forces the group to relocate to a new base on Momoiro Island.
Law and Blackbeard’s Duel Was Pure Hype Despite Being Partially Off-Screened



Blackbeard’s most recent clash in One Piece wasn’t one that most fans saw coming. When Trafalgar D. Law, Eustass Kid, and Monkey D. Luffy left Wano, they each went their separate ways, with Law having the unfortunate honor of running into the Blackbeard Pirates upon reaching Winner Island.




